parid0386
| Sat, 22 Feb 2003 16:16:43
The subject matter of the section doesn't seem to match the heading, which reinforces for me the notion that "humans are the ultimate arbiters of subject identity." But the text talks about the responsbiolities of topic map "creators" which is a different kettle of fish.
parid0386
| Sat, 22 Feb 2003 16:16:43
I'm very uncomfortable with the word "creator", first because of its vaguely religious aura, second because see no reason why the entity of origin for a topic map has to be human, and, in the case where it isn't, where I am to look to discover "intent." Isn't this paragraph really speaking to what the nature of the authority behind any given topic map must be? And won't these authorities get such autority as they possess pragmatically? It seems to me that "must accept responsbility" boils down to following the 10 point checklist, which does or should include signing up for the SLUO, but I don't see what more can or need be done that that. |